Select Page
Free Printable Toast Gingerbread Cookies Template
Free to print. The PDF opens in a new tab, so this page stays open for the steps. Print tips
Toast cookies made from gingerbread: buttered toast, jam toast, a kawaii toast face, a peanut butter and jelly triangle, fairy bread, a Christmas toast and a toaster on a wooden board
Seven designs from one batch of dough. AI rendering.

Toast cookies are breakfast you can hand round at dessert. A golden slice with a pat of butter sliding off the middle looks so much like the real thing that someone always reaches for the jam.

This set uses one free printable template with three shapes, a gingerbread cut-out dough that bakes flat enough for a slice of bread and the royal icing cure times from our icing pages. It is written for anyone filling a Christmas morning breakfast board, planning a brunch, or decorating with small kids who love anything cute.

You get an icing palette, three steps for each design, a picker and a brunch batch planner. Start with the recipe card, then the shapes.

Toast Gingerbread Cookies
Makes about 24 cookies, 2 3/4 inch slices, 2 1/2 inch half slice triangles and 3 1/4 inch toasters · Prep 30 minutes · Bake 11 minutes · Chill and freeze 2 hours 30 minutes · Icing cure overnight, 8 hours
Total time about 11 hours, most of it hands off. The overnight cure is what lets you stack them on a platter.

Equipment: Stand or hand mixer, Rolling pin with 1/4 inch guides, The free template, or a bread slice cookie cutter for the slices, A small paring knife, Two light-colored half sheet pans, Parchment paper, Piping bags with small round tips.

Template: free 1-page PDF, US Letter, a bread slice, a half slice cut on the diagonal and a toaster with two slices popping up, with crust guides and a 1 inch test bar.

Ingredients

Dough

  • 3 cups all-purpose flour, 360 g, spooned and levelled
  • 1 teaspoon baking soda
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 1 tablespoon ground ginger
  • 1 1/2 teaspoons ground cinnamon
  • 1/2 teaspoon ground cloves
  • 1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg
  • 3/4 cup unsalted butter, 170 g, softened but still cool
  • 3/4 cup dark brown sugar, packed, 150 g
  • 1/2 cup unsulphured molasses, 170 g
  • 1 large egg
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract

Royal icing, a double batch

  • 1/4 cup meringue powder
  • 1/2 cup cold water, plus a few drops more for flooding
  • 1/2 teaspoon cream of tartar
  • 4 cups confectioners sugar, unsifted, 454 g
  • Gel food coloring in the shades from the palette chart
  • Rainbow nonpareils, optional, for the fairy bread
  • For the no-bake toast: graham crackers, pink frosting and yellow candy melts, optional

Method

  1. Make the dough: whisk the flour, soda, salt and spices, cream the butter and brown sugar until lighter in color, beat in the molasses, egg and vanilla, then mix in the dry ingredients on low and stop the moment no dry flour remains.
  2. Chill the dough as two flat wrapped discs about an inch thick for 2 hours, until a pressed thumb leaves a clean dent rather than a smear.
  3. Roll each disc to 1/4 inch between two sheets of parchment, so the dough never picks up extra flour.
  4. Lay the template on the dough and cut the slices, half slice triangles and toasters with a small knife held straight up, cutting the notch where the two toaster slices overlap with the tip.
  5. Freeze the cut shapes on the parchment-lined pan for 30 minutes, until the shoulders of the slices and the tips of the triangles feel hard and lift without bending.
  6. Bake at 350F for 9 to 11 minutes straight from the freezer, until the surface looks matte and the edges are set, with the triangles on their own tray because their tips brown first, then cool completely on the pan.
  7. Mix the icing to stiff peaks, tint a big bowl toast gold, and tint the rest into the colors your designs need from the palette chart.
  8. Flood toast gold inside each dashed crust line so the bare edge stays as the crust, add the wet-on-wet jam, cheeks and sprinkles straight away, leave the cookies flat overnight, then pipe the butter pats, faces, gingerbread men and toaster details the next day.

Notes: times are worked out from the set times on our icing pages, not timed on a build, and ovens vary, so judge by the surface rather than the clock. The yield is an estimate: a batch rolls to about 162 usable square inches at 1/4 inch, and the three shapes average 6.3 square inches, which gives about 25, rounded down to 24. Bake one test tray before you shop for a big brunch. Dough adapted from King Arthur Baking gingerbread cut-outs.

Many searches for toast cookies want the chewy one that went around social media. That version butters and jams warm toast, then blitzes it into crumbs that go into the dough and round the outside, so it tastes like toast. These are the other kind: gingerbread iced to look like toast. For both on one table, set the jam toast design beside a tray of the crumb cookies.

A tan square reads as a cracker. Toast has a few tells, and each shape on the template is built round the one people check first.

Toast The detail that gives it away What the template does with it
A slice of sandwich bread The domed top that bulges out past the sides, like the top of the loaf A crown that overhangs the body at the shoulders, with a small notch where they meet
The crust A darker band all the way round a lighter middle A dashed crust line inset from the edge: you ice inside it and the bare gingerbread plays the crust
Toast cut for a lunchbox or a party A triangle with crust on two sides and soft crumb along the cut A half slice with the crust guide on the two straight outer sides only
Toast that just popped up Two golden slices standing out of the slots A side view toaster with two rounded slices rising out of the top and a slot line across the body

The bare edge is the whole trick. Gingerbread bakes darker than bread, so instead of fighting it, every design floods the middle a warm toast gold and stops at the crust line. The brown ring left showing is the crust, and it looks right because it was never painted.

The word has a story. Toast comes from the Latin torrere, to burn, and toasting most likely started as a way to make stale bread good to eat again. The same page reports a 2001 test that found a buttered slice dropped from a table landed butter-side down at least 62 percent of the time. The buttered toast cookie beats those odds, because its butter is royal icing and sets hard overnight.

Three of the designs carry real facts too. Fairy bread is white bread spread with butter and covered in hundreds and thousands, the tiny round sprinkles, typically cut into triangles and often served at children’s parties in Australia and New Zealand, which is why the fairy bread cookie is a triangle. Peanut butter and jelly first showed up in print in a 1901 article by Julia Davis Chandler in the Boston Cooking School Magazine. Charles Strite patented the automatic pop-up toaster in 1921, and the toaster cookie freezes that pop-up moment.

The fried egg cookie set already has an egg on toast design, so this set leaves the egg off and puts the slice itself in the spotlight.

One Template, 3 Bread Slice Shapes

Every baked design starts as one of three cookies on a single page: a slice about 2 3/4 inches square, a half slice triangle about 2 1/2 inches on its straight sides, and a toaster about 3 1/4 inches wide.

Toast cookies template: a bread slice with crust, butter pat and face guides, a half slice triangle and a toaster with two slices popping up
The free template: three shapes, one page.

The free template prints on one US Letter page at 100 percent. Measure the red bar first: if it is not exactly 1 inch, your printer scaled the page.

The red dashed lines are icing guides, not cut lines: the crust line, the butter pat square, the smile and the eye circles on the slice, and the slot line and stripe on the toaster. Ignore any guide your design does not use.

A script checked the parts most likely to snap. The crown overhangs the body by 0.16 inches on each side, the triangle is still 0.47 inches thick half an inch from each point, the two staggered toaster slices are 1.95 inches wide where they rise out of the slot, and every inside corner opens at least 90 degrees, wide enough for the tip of a paring knife. Every guide sits inside its cut line. If you own a bread slice cookie cutter, use it for the slices and keep the paper for the triangle and the toaster.

Icing Palette for All 8 Designs

Each row lists the colors one design needs, so you can mix only those bowls. Gel brands vary, so test a spoonful on a scrap cookie first.

Design Shape Colors and what they cover Difficulty
The Buttered Toast with a Melting Pat Bread slice template toast gold for the slice inside the crust; butter yellow for the melting pat Easy
The Strawberry Jam Toast Bread slice template toast gold for the slice inside the crust; jam red for the jam spread Easy
The Kawaii Toast with a Happy Face Bread slice template toast gold for the slice inside the crust; blush pink for the cheeks; coal black for the eyes and smile; shine white for the eye shine Medium
The Peanut Butter and Jelly Triangle Half slice template peanut butter tan for the spread; grape purple for the jelly along the cut edge Medium
The Fairy Bread Triangle Half slice template soft white for the buttered bread; rainbow nonpareils for the all over the top Easy
The Christmas Toast with a Gingerbread Man Bread slice template toast gold for the slice inside the crust; cranberry red for the jam spread; gingerbread brown for the little gingerbread man; icing white for the squiggles and buttons Hard
Toast Popping out of a Toaster Toaster template retro mint for the toaster body; toast gold for the two slices inside the crust; chrome silver for the stripe; coal black for the slot line and lever Hard
No-Bake Toast Cookies for Little Kids Store-bought graham cracker squares strawberry pink for the jam frosting; butter yellow for the candy melt pat Easy

Toast gold goes on five of the designs, so mix a full cup of it. Coal black covers two designs, the kawaii face and the toaster. A buttered, jam, kawaii and peanut butter and jelly platter needs 8 bowls, while a buttered and jam platter needs only 3. The picker shows each design’s swatches, steps and difficulty, or picks one from how the toast lover in your house takes theirs.


Which Toast Cookie Should You Make?
Pick a design to see its icing colors, its three steps and how hard it is. Or say how they take their toast, filter by skill, or let the button choose.

For ideas only: these palettes are original color choices and gel brands vary in shade, so tint a little and test on a scrap cookie. Nothing you pick leaves your browser.


Difficulty follows one rule. Easy means one flood and one topping or detail. Medium means a two-stage job, where one color has to crust before the next goes on. Hard means three or more icing areas plus fine piping on one cookie.

Ingredient Notes

The dough is a cut-out dough on purpose. It bakes flat with sharp edges. A soft dough puffs, the shoulders melt into a round top and the toaster slot closes.

Meringue powder, not raw egg whites. Royal icing is never cooked and a brunch platter sits out for hours, so use meringue powder, dried egg white sold as a pasteurized product. For flood consistency and the full cure table, see the ten second rule for flood icing that settles flat.

Toast gold is the color that matters most. Mix a little yellow and a touch of brown gel into white. Too yellow and the slice looks like cheese, too brown and it disappears into the crust, so test it next to the bare edge on a scrap cookie.

How to Make Toast Cookies Step by Step

1.Make the dough

Cream the butter and brown sugar, beat in the molasses, egg and vanilla, then mix in the whisked dry ingredients on low and stop the moment no dry flour remains.

2.Chill the dough

Chill two flat wrapped discs for 2 hours, until a pressed thumb leaves a clean dent.

3.Roll the dough

Roll each disc to 1/4 inch between two sheets of parchment. Keep it even: a thin patch under a triangle tip is where it browns too fast and snaps.

4.Cut the slices, triangles and toasters

Cut round the template with a paring knife held straight up, and cut the shoulder notches with two short strokes. On the toaster, cut the notch where the slices overlap last with the knife tip.

Toast cookies cut from rolled gingerbread dough on parchment: bread slices, half slice triangles and toaster shapes with two slices popping up
Slices, triangles and toasters on parchment, ready for the freezer. AI rendering.

5.Freeze the shapes

Freeze the cut shapes on their parchment for 30 minutes, until the shoulders and tips feel hard. Cold shoulders stay crisp in the oven.

6.Bake at 350F

Bake for 9 to 11 minutes straight from the freezer. Put the triangles on their own tray if you can, because their thin tips brown before the middle of a slice is done, and they may be ready a minute or so sooner. Judge everything by the surface rather than the clock: matte all over, with edges that are set. Let everything cool completely on the pan.

7.Mix and color the icing

Beat the icing to stiff peaks, tint a big bowl toast gold and the rest from the palette chart. Thin the flood colors and keep a little butter yellow, black, brown and white stiff for pats, faces and fine lines.

8.Flood the toast and add the toppings

Flood toast gold inside each dashed crust line and add anything that should sink in flat while it is wet: the jam, the pink cheeks, the nonpareils. Leave the cookies flat overnight, then pipe the pats, faces, gingerbread men and toaster details and give them about 2 hours before anything touches them.

Toast cookies drying on parchment, freshly flooded with toast gold, peanut butter tan, soft white and retro mint, the bare gingerbread crust showing round each slice, no details yet
The flood coats, drying before the butter, faces and details go on. AI rendering.

Say you are decorating with a five-year-old who wants to do it all. Flood the toast gold the night before, then hand over a bag of butter yellow and let them pipe the pats. A lopsided pat looks even more like butter that slid, because no one ever puts butter on toast in a perfect square.

Each design lists its colors, difficulty and three short steps, plus a no-bake toast for the youngest helpers. Four designs share the slice and two share the triangle. Only the kawaii toast has a face.

1.The Buttered Toast with a Melting Pat

Toast cookies: a buttered toast gingerbread cookie with a toast gold slice, a bare gingerbread crust and a melting butter yellow pat
The buttered toast with a melting pat. AI rendering.

Colors: toast gold, butter yellow. Difficulty: Easy.

The one everybody draws when you say toast, and the best first cookie in the set. The drip off one corner is what makes the butter look warm, so pull it down and stop. For cinnamon sugar toast, skip the pat and shake cinnamon mixed with white sanding sugar over the wet gold.

  1. Flood toast gold inside the dashed crust line, leaving the bare gingerbread edge as the crust, and let it crust for an hour.
  2. Pipe a thick butter yellow square on the pat guide, then pull one corner down into a short, rounded drip so it looks like it is melting.
  3. Leave the cookie flat overnight so the pat sets up proud of the toast.

2.The Strawberry Jam Toast

Toast cookies: a strawberry jam toast gingerbread cookie with a glossy red jam spread on a toast gold slice and a bare gingerbread crust
The strawberry jam toast. AI rendering.

Colors: toast gold, jam red. Difficulty: Easy.

Two colors and one move. Dropping the red into wet gold lets it sink in flat, so the jam looks spread with a knife instead of piped on top. Keep a ring of toast showing all the way round.

  1. Flood toast gold inside the dashed crust line.
  2. While it is still wet, spoon jam red into the middle and nudge it out with a toothpick into a wobbly spread that stops well short of the crust.
  3. Leave the cookie flat overnight, and the jam dries level and shiny like a fresh spread.

3.The Kawaii Toast with a Happy Face

Toast cookies: a kawaii toast gingerbread cookie with two round black eyes, a small smile and pink cheeks on a toast gold slice
The kawaii toast with a happy face. AI rendering.

Colors: toast gold, blush pink, coal black, shine white. Difficulty: Medium.

The one kids fight over. Set the face low and keep the eyes far apart: a face near the crown looks surprised, a face down low looks sweet.

  1. Flood toast gold inside the dashed crust line and drop a blush pink dot just outside each eye circle while it is wet, so the cheeks sink in flat.
  2. Leave it flat overnight, then pipe a round coal black eye on each dotted circle and a thin smile along the guide.
  3. Add one tiny shine white dot at the top of each eye while the black is still soft.

4.The Peanut Butter and Jelly Triangle

Toast cookies: a peanut butter and jelly triangle gingerbread cookie with swirled peanut butter tan icing and a wavy grape jelly band along the cut edge
The peanut butter and jelly triangle. AI rendering.

Colors: peanut butter tan, grape purple. Difficulty: Medium.

A lunchbox classic cut the way most kids ask for it. The jelly goes along the cut edge, not in the middle, because that is where jelly squeezes out of a real sandwich.

  1. Flood peanut butter tan inside the crust line and drag a toothpick through it in loose swirls before it sets, then let it crust for an hour.
  2. Flood a wavy grape purple band along the diagonal cut edge, about a third of an inch wide, with soft bumps on its inner side.
  3. Leave the cookie flat overnight so the jelly stays glossy and the swirls stay sharp.

5.The Fairy Bread Triangle

Toast cookies: a fairy bread triangle gingerbread cookie covered edge to edge in rainbow nonpareils with a bare gingerbread crust
The fairy bread triangle. AI rendering.

Colors: soft white, rainbow nonpareils. Difficulty: Easy.

The easiest cookie here to make look spectacular. Use nonpareils, not long jimmies, and cover every bit of white, because a bald patch is the only thing that gives it away.

  1. Flood soft white inside the crust line.
  2. Tip rainbow nonpareils over the wet icing straight away until no white shows, then press them lightly with a clean fingertip.
  3. Leave the cookie flat overnight, then tip it on its side over the bowl to shake off the loose ones.

6.The Christmas Toast with a Gingerbread Man

Toast cookies: a Christmas toast gingerbread cookie with a cranberry red jam spread and a tiny piped gingerbread man with white squiggles
The Christmas toast with a gingerbread man. AI rendering.

Colors: toast gold, cranberry red, gingerbread brown, icing white. Difficulty: Hard.

A gingerbread man on gingerbread toast. Keep him about an inch tall so a ring of jam shows round him.

  1. Flood toast gold inside the dashed crust line and let it crust for an hour, then flood a cranberry red spread in the middle with a wobbly edge.
  2. Leave it flat overnight, then pipe a little gingerbread man in gingerbread brown on the jam: a round head, a body and four short stubby limbs.
  3. Once the brown has crusted, about an hour later, pipe white squiggles across the arms and legs and two white dots for buttons.

7.Toast Popping out of a Toaster

Toast cookies: a toaster gingerbread cookie in retro mint with two toast gold slices popping out, a silver stripe and a black lever
Toast popping out of a toaster. AI rendering.

Colors: retro mint, toast gold, chrome silver, coal black. Difficulty: Hard.

The slowest to finish, so make one or two as the centerpiece rather than a dozen. Any pastel works for the toaster.

  1. Flood the toaster body retro mint below the slot line and each slice toast gold inside its crust line, leaving a hairline of bare cookie between them, and leave it flat overnight.
  2. Pipe a chrome silver stripe along the lower guide, a little thicker than a line, so it reads as a metal band.
  3. Pipe a thin coal black line along the slot guide and a small black lever on the right side, near the top of the body.

No-Bake Toast Cookies for Little Kids

Toast cookies no-bake version: graham cracker squares spread with pink frosting short of the edge with a yellow candy melt as the butter
Graham cracker squares turned into jam toast. AI rendering.

Colors: strawberry pink, butter yellow. Difficulty: Easy, no oven.

For a table of four-year-olds, or a morning the oven is busy. Stopping the frosting short of the edge is the clever bit: the bare cracker round it reads as crust, and the candy melt does the rest.

  1. Break graham crackers into squares and spread each with strawberry pink frosting using the back of a spoon, stopping a little short of the edge.
  2. Press one yellow candy melt into the middle of the frosting, a little off center, as the pat of butter.
  3. Set them on a plate for ten minutes so the frosting firms before anyone picks one up.

Toast Cookies for a Brunch or Party

Toast cookies land best when they are set out the way breakfast is. How you serve them depends on the crowd.

  • If it is a Christmas morning breakfast board, lean on the buttered and Christmas toast and set them beside the iced milk glass cookies from Santa’s plate.
  • If it is a kid’s birthday, make fairy bread the star and let the guests pipe their own butter pats, with the no-bake toast for the youngest.
  • If it is a brunch or a teacher gift, box one buttered, one jam and one kawaii slice with a toaster on top.

The planner below does the math for cookies, shapes, batches, colors and days. It works the dough out from the size of each shape, because a toaster uses almost twice the dough of a half slice triangle.


Toast Brunch Cookie Planner
Enter the guests, the cookies each and the brunch date, then tick the designs. It works out the dough batches from how big each shape is, how many of each to cut, the icing colors and which day each job falls on.

Designs

For planning only: the dough per batch figure is an estimate and dough rolls out differently in every kitchen, so bake one test tray before you shop for a big brunch. The no-bake version is not counted because it uses store-bought cookies. Nothing you enter leaves your browser.


Picture a brunch for 12 on a Saturday, with the buttered, the jam, the kawaii and the peanut butter and jelly ticked. The planner calls for 14 cookies, one batch of dough and one double batch of icing in 8 colors, with 4 buttered, 4 jam, 3 kawaii and 3 peanut butter and jelly. Cut a toaster from the leftover dough as the centerpiece. Bake and flood on Wednesday, pipe on Thursday, and Friday stays free in case a triangle tip snaps.

Troubleshooting

Symptom Cause Fix
The slice baked into a plain round-topped square Soft dough, so the shoulders melted Freeze the cut shapes for the full 30 minutes and cut the shoulder notches with two straight strokes
A triangle tip burned or snapped Thin dough at the tip, or triangles baked beside the bigger slices Roll an even 1/4 inch and give the triangles their own tray
The toaster slot closed up The sliver of dough was left in, or the dough was warm Lift the sliver out with the knife point and bake straight from the freezer
The jam sits on top like a sticker Jam piped onto gold that had already crusted Drop it into the gold while it is wet so it sinks in flat
Nonpareils bled color into the white Sprinkles sat in wet icing on a humid day Sprinkle each cookie right after flooding and dry them in still air

Make-Ahead and Timeline

Plan on three days: bake and flood on day one, pipe details on day two, box or bag on day three. For a big brunch, freeze the plain cookies flat in an airtight container and thaw them in it so condensation forms on the outside. For how long decorated cookies stay good to eat, see how many days iced gingerbread keeps at room temperature.

Storage Instructions

Once the icing has cured, store the cookies in a single layer or with parchment between layers, in an airtight tin at room temperature and away from sunlight, which fades the jam red and the mint fast.

Never store them in the bread bin, where real bread keeps the air damp and softens the icing. Give them the full overnight royal icing cure before any stacking, and the faces and pats will not smudge.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do toast cookies taste like toast?

Not these ones. They are spiced gingerbread under sweet royal icing, so they taste like a crisp holiday cookie. Only the look comes from the toast. The viral jam toast cookie is the one with real toast in the dough.

How far ahead can I make toast cookies?

Baked, undecorated shapes freeze for up to about 3 months. Decorated cookies keep about two weeks in an airtight tin once cured, so decorating three days ahead leaves plenty of margin.

Pair the Cookies with a Best Gingerbread Houses Kit Pick

When the brunch wants something to build too, skip baking walls and start from a gingerbread house kit to build after breakfast, then pass the toast round while the icing sets.

Our top gingerbread house kit picks of 2026›